Introduction
India’s middle class is growing increasingly frustrated. The reasons vary, from failing infrastructure to mismanaged tax money.
The Pothole Predicament
Our roads are full of potholes, almost like one big pothole. This might sound funny, but it’s a serious issue. In the last three weeks, 13 bridges have collapsed in Bihar. Airport pillars are falling on cars. If our tax money is being wasted like this, why are we paying taxes?
Infrastructure Miseries
A popular meme on Twitter captures this perfectly: “India has European-level taxes and Russian-level corruption. China has labor laws, and America has wokeness. Yet, our infrastructure is like sub-Saharan regions. And we talk about becoming a world guru.” This shows that the problem is not just the bad conditions, but also the lack of accountability.
The Taxpayer’s Plight
In India, only a small number of people pay income tax, around 1-2%, maybe up to 5%. These taxpayers don’t protest or destroy property, so their voices are often ignored. With the budget coming up, it’s important to address why the middle class is worried and how we can help improve their lives.
Simplifying Tax Filing
If taxes stress you out, ClearTax can help you file your taxes in minutes. For salaried employees, it’s easy:
1. Link your PAN card
2. Upload Form 16
3. Watch your details auto-fill
ClearTax will pick the best tax-saving options for you, correctly capture capital gains, add crypto income and US stocks data, and even handle notices for free. Use the discount code CTANN to get an extra 10% off.
The Pain of Promotion
Good news: you’ve been promoted, and your salary went up by 6%. But now you’re in the 30% tax bracket instead of 20%, so you pay more taxes on your extra income. With 6% inflation, the cost of cars, school fees, and daily essentials also goes up by 6%. Your promotion doesn’t feel real because your spending power stays the same. This is called fiscal drag, where higher income is offset by inflation and taxes, reducing your disposable income.
Tax Structure Needs Overhaul
The tax brackets haven’t changed since 2014. The old structure is still in place even though the new tax regime offers fewer deductions, which discourages people from switching. According to the Economic Times, the real value of 10 lakhs ten years ago is now just 5.6 lakhs. Yet, the Income Tax Department hasn’t adjusted for this drop in value.
Learning from Others
Countries like the US, Finland, France, the Netherlands, and Germany adjust their tax brackets every year or two to account for inflation. This way, taxes are based on real income, making it easier on taxpayers.
The Gold Standard
In 2005, 1 gram of gold cost Rs. 690. Today, 145 grams of gold from 2005 would be worth Rs. 10.5 lakhs. Based on this, the current tax structure should adjust:
– Income below 10 lakhs should be tax-free
– 10% tax on income from 10 lakhs to 15 lakhs
– 20% tax on income from 15 lakhs to 25 lakhs
– 30% tax on income above 25 lakhs
This would provide significant relief to the middle class.
The Double Tax Burden
The middle class faces both direct and indirect taxes. Customs duties, GST, and service taxes hit them hard. For instance, buying an iPhone in India costs Rs. 41,000 more than in the US due to customs duties. Indirect taxes like GST are regressive, affecting the poor more.
Disparity in Taxation
Salaried employees bear the brunt of direct taxes. In 2018-19, salaried taxpayers paid much more tax than business owners, despite similar numbers of taxpayers in both groups.
The Brain Drain
High taxes are not the only problem; it’s the lack of return on taxes. Talented Indians move abroad where their taxes contribute to better infrastructure and services. This talent drain hinders India’s progress.
Solutions
1. Work-Reward System
States that manage their funds responsibly should be rewarded. For example, Maharashtra gets only 8 paise back for every rupee it contributes in taxes, while Bihar gets Rs. 7.60. Funds should be allocated based on accountability and responsible spending.
2. Tax Agricultural Income
Agricultural income is tax-free in India, which is often misused. Taxing high agricultural income can prevent this misuse. From 2007-08 to 2015-16, many entities declared crores in agricultural income to evade taxes.
3. Rewarding Taxpayers
Other countries reward taxpayers in various ways. Japan celebrates tax season, Malta has a tax lottery, and Pakistan offers VIP benefits to top taxpayers. India should adopt similar practices, recognizing and rewarding honest taxpayers.
Conclusion
India’s middle class is the backbone of the nation. They deserve better infrastructure, responsible use of tax money, and recognition. By addressing these issues, we can improve their lives and strengthen the country. Share this article and demand better services and accountability from the government. Together, we can make a difference.
FAQs
Q1: Why is India’s middle class unhappy?
A1: The middle class is unhappy because of poor infrastructure, how tax money is managed, and a lack of government accountability.
Q2: How does bad infrastructure affect daily life?
A2: Bad infrastructure, like broken bridges and endless potholes, makes travel unsafe and increases commute times, affecting overall quality of life.
Q3: Why is there a meme about India’s infrastructure?
A3: The meme highlights the frustration with high taxes and corruption while pointing out that our infrastructure is still very poor.
Q4: How many people in India pay income tax?
A4: Only about 1-2% of people pay income tax, though some estimates go up to 5%.
Q5: What is fiscal drag, and how does it affect the middle class?
A5: Fiscal drag is when inflation and taxes cancel out income increases, leaving the middle class with less spending money despite higher salaries.
Q6: Why does India’s tax structure need to change?
A6: The tax brackets haven’t changed since 2014 and don’t account for inflation, which means people are paying more tax on less valuable income.
Q7: How do other countries adjust their tax brackets for inflation?
A7: Countries like the US, Finland, France, Netherlands, and Germany adjust their tax brackets every year or two to ensure taxes are based on real income.
Q8: What changes are suggested for India’s tax structure?
A8: Suggested changes include making income below 10 lakhs tax-free, taxing income from 10 to 15 lakhs at 10%, from 15 to 25 lakhs at 20%, and above 25 lakhs at 30%.
Q9: How do indirect taxes affect the middle class?
A9: Indirect taxes like customs duties and GST make goods and services more expensive, hitting the middle class hard.
Q10: Why do talented Indians move abroad, and how does it relate to taxes?
A10: Talented Indians move abroad for better infrastructure and services, as they feel their taxes are not well-spent in India.
Q11: What solutions are proposed to address the middle class’s concerns?
A11: Solutions include rewarding states that manage their funds well, taxing high agricultural income to prevent misuse, and adopting practices from other countries to reward honest taxpayers.
Q12: How can ClearTax help with tax filing for salaried individuals?
A12: ClearTax simplifies tax filing by linking your PAN card, uploading Form 16, and auto-filling details. It chooses the best tax-saving options, includes capital gains, crypto income, and US stock data, and manages notices.
Q13: Are there any special offers with ClearTax?
A13: Yes, you can get an additional 10% off with the discount code CTANN.
Q14: How can addressing middle class issues strengthen India?
A14: Improving infrastructure, ensuring responsible use of tax money, and recognizing taxpayers can improve the middle class’s quality of life and strengthen the country.
Directly speaks to the frustrations and challenges faced by the middle class, encouraging clicks and shares.
Keywords: “India’s Middle Class,” “Taxes,” “Infrastructure,” “Economic Burdens”
About The Author
